Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Xavier Moss's avatar

While all the examples are true, I don't really find the overall narrative tracing this to some particular leftist thought persuasive. Excusing dictators on 'our' side while condemning those on 'theirs' is a shameful but time-honoured tradition across the political spectrum – Pinochet, Hussein, Mobutu, MBS have all received strong support from the right or even the centre, and Assad for example has plenty of fans on both the left and the right because Syrian politics is so complex even the tankies can't figure out whose crimes they're meant to excuse.

I worry that ascribing this tendency to a particular strain of hard leftist though implicitly denies it in the rest of us – that they have this original sin that leads them to whitewash dictators that the rest of us don't. We'd be better off treating this as a human tendency to let taking sides cloud our moral judgement and excuse the inexcusable, and be ever vigilant as a result. I don't think there's a consistent philosophy behind it, just power and tribalism.

Expand full comment
Steve Stoft's avatar

Thanks for covering this important topic. I found the historical context particularly helpful. My far-left Democratic friends tend to admit that the CPUSA made such mistakes before Kruschev, but refuse to beleive this is a continuing problem.

While your list of links to prominent left-wingers is quite helpful, I would love to see a sequel post that provides memorable, concrete, recent examples. I think those would prove to be persuasive to a wider audience. It might also help if you showed that moderate Dems do not often make such mistakes.

Expand full comment
8 more comments...

No posts