Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Michael Berkowitz's avatar

"Zero-tolerance" policies are stupid by definition -- they are saying explicitly "We are not going to think about this, we are going to behave in automatic, i.e. unintelligent, ways."

This is how we get to cases like Cavani's, or little boys expelled from school for bringing plastic butter knives to make their lunch sandwiches.

I mention this because I've seen a tendency to think that there are good-and-bad ZTPs, and we just need to keep the good ones and weed out the bad ones. No. There is never a good enough reason for installing an Off switch on our minds, and there's no such thing as a ZTP that can't lead to an idiotic -- not to mention unfair and harmful -- application.

Expand full comment
C. A. Meyer's avatar

Everyone left-of-center in the US should read this. The harsh racial lines in the US don’t necessarily reflect global cultural attitudes. This article reminds me of an experience I had several years ago. I met a friend visiting from Shanghai in NYC. We stopped for a cocktail at a chic bar. She invited a friend from South Korea to join us. Let’s call the friend Lee. Our server was Indian. As he was walking away from the table, Lee openly began to imitate his accent and mannerisms. My friend and I cringed, and told Lee that in the US, making fun of other races is considered taboo. She asked why. We started to explain but quickly realized we were falling into a cultural abyss. There was no way to bridge the gap and why should we.

The harsh racial relations in America are unique. Native peoples were wiped out. Slavery ruled for two hundred years. The mingling of races was illegal until recently. The Right tries to downplay this history; the Left now makes it the center of everything. In reality, America has little to teach the rest of the world about race relations.

Expand full comment
13 more comments...

No posts