Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Mitch Berbrier's avatar

Hello. I’m Dr so-and-so. I have discovered the cure to cancer but I cannot publish my research because I refuse to submit a positionalty statement, insisting that my work be judged on whether or not it cures cancer. Oh well, nevermind.

Expand full comment
Ralph J Hodosh's avatar

If the authors feel the need or are required to include positionality statements, that is a clear indication that independent researchers may not be able to reproduce the results following the authors' materials and methods. Results that cannot be reproduced independently are not science and should not be published. Often when independent researchers fail to reproduce published results, editors are forced to retract scientific publications. Retracted publications indicate shoddy research, poor editing or, worst case, fraud.

Expand full comment
12 more comments...

No posts