Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Ray Andrews's avatar

I take it the gentleman could continue to serve without any hindrance at all if he would only admit that he is a male? The military is, perhaps of all places, a place where reality matters. Identity does not. I suspect that the military would probably look the other way if Col. Fram wanted to cross-dress on his off-duty time -- tho even there, one might expect that the military would want their officers to be completely mentally healthy 24/7 -- but on duty one's mental disturbances should be stowed. Col. Fram reports that his subordinates are completely happy with him Identifying as a woman. I'd not be happy myself anymore than I'd be happy serving under someone who Identified as a Martian.

Expand full comment
Deborah's avatar

I do not care if someone wants to identify as a gender other than their biological sex as long as they do not expect me to participate in pretending that they are actually the opposite sex, which is biologically impossible, or to provide courtesy and respect beyond what I would for any other person. However, serving in the military is a privilege not a right, and transgenders in the military is not about the transgender person, it is about the mission of the military and its purpose to defend our country. Our military members must be mentally and physically healthy and also to know and trust that anyone they serve with is the same, in any situation that troops may be in. Transgender people can cause confusion and uncertainty among members of a unit that depends on trust and cohesion to do the job, and this is a distraction that, if the transgender person actually understood the mission and culture of the military, would not want to cause for the other service members. Further, depending on how far a transgender person has gone in their transition, he/she may require daily hormone medication and maybe other interventions as well to maintain their semblance of the sex that they are not. There are many serious health consequences to taking cross sex hormones which very likely will affect the person's fitness to serve. In a deployment situation, the hormones may not be readily available and the transgender person could suffer from mental or physical health issues as a consequence, and it's not hard to imagine how that could affect the ability of a deployed unit to carry out their mission, or to handle an encounter with the enemy. Transgenders need to stand down and do something else to serve if they are so inclined, but not in any branch of the US military.

Expand full comment
73 more comments...

No posts