Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Jay Hinman's avatar

I truly have a hard time squaring the “liberals hope/assume that immigrants are antagonistic to American culture” take with my own lifelong experience. I have found that immigrants’ love of America to be one of the best things about this country, and something celebrated by liberals and non-liberals for decades. EVERYONE tears up at citizenship ceremonies. To think that there is this mass of liberals openly hoping that immigrants will turn anti-America is ridiculous, and probably founded, as most tropes are, on the actions of a tiny handful of “progressives” who in no way speak for the great majority of liberals and/or Democrats.

Expand full comment
Jeff Wu's avatar

As a child of immigrant parents, I deeply resonated with this article. I hold a reverence, perhaps almost naively, of American institutions and values. I believe that this is why America is a great country, one that allows people to be free and prosperous, and yet doesn’t descend into chaos because of a strong shared belief in those values.

For me, this was what hurt the most about 2016 election. That day, we elected a man that I felt was the antithesis of these values, indeed a man that I thought was the opposite of a decent human being, to lead this great country. I didn’t realize how much the *idea* of America meant to me until that day

Expand full comment
9 more comments...

No posts