Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Charles Buell's avatar

I absolutely agree with Penny Adrian that "If the Dems want to win back the working class--across racial lines--they will have to take wages, housing and crime MUCH more seriously than they do now." But Trump's success has as much to do with cultural issues as economic ones. Feminism undercutting the role of the man of the house and the rise of the black and hispanic "native" minorities and the influx of non-caucasian Asians are visible samples of their perceived loss of status. Hillary Clinton's "deplorables" comment helped her lose the 2016 election and cemented their anger. These cultural issues will take a long time to resolve, but real advancement in the issues of wages, housing and and crime will help.

Expand full comment
jt's avatar

Like a lotta times, I agree with some-a this, but not other parts. Some observations for M Mounk (if he so desires):

"The problem is that one day the gamble is not going to pay off. And that is why I find it immoral to take that risk."

I think it's somewhat funny to use the word "immoral" in this context. To judge the Ds actions from a *moral* POV, then whether it pays off or not doesn't even enter the conversation. It's a scurrilous way of conducting politics, if looked at strictly *morally,* right? Or not?

"There are certainly many things about Ron DeSantis I dislike, certainly many policies he has taken that break the kind of norms that I think governors of large states should observe."

I would need some examples, before I formed an opinion on this view. I suspect You mean You dislike some-a the *policies* rather than that they "break the kind of norms"... But ICBW.

To M Luce (if he so desires):

Thank You for Your views. Agree with a lot, or most, of them.

"to have a young candidate with kids (and he's always pictured with his kids) talking God in the way he talks God with a really quite terrifying sincerity, to judge by that ad. That concerns me."

I'm 50% Fundamentalist Atheist. I was raised that Way and never lost that core. I didn't see that ad, but I don't find it intellectually satisfying to decry how a man of faith portrays himself. As long as he recognizes the separation of Church and State, and doesn't insist others follow his *particular* Religion, I wouldn't see it as "terrifying."

"I cannot agree with you more that this sort of Pavlovian tendency to say that any Republican is just as bad as Trump is a horribly polarizing instinct amongst Democrats."

I think You, M Luce said this. Whoever.. I likewise agree. TYTY.

"But to the degree that there's an overlap between polarization and racialization, there is a greater risk to the stability of America. So this, to me, reduces some of the temperature."

You're right. Virtually all Ds would hate to hear You say this. Mebbe that just proves how correct it is.

"But because the Democrats did pretty well this week, I suspect that they're not going to revisit first principles on that. I would say, though, that even though he lost, Tim Ryan's campaign in Ohio was a model campaign.."

I believe Tim Ryan had Joe Manchin help him out at one point. That may, or may not, increase Your approbation of his campaign. Me? I dunno how many what-I-call "middle-a the road Ds" are out there. Like to see more-a them. The identity politics of the far left is gonna kill You, IMO. No crystal ball, of course.

Expand full comment
2 more comments...

No posts