Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Peter Partee's avatar

Beautifully written and analytically correct. To eliminate racism, one must change hearts and minds, not just conduct. As the Stoics taught us, violence cannot do that. If anything, it hardens inclinations into immovable concrete and elicits resentment. One must disabuse, and that requires understanding the root cause of another's belief. Antiracism as currently configured completely fails to acknowledge this truth and instead takes the easy, emotionally satisfying tack of confrontation and use of war-like techniques to best, intimidate and cow. It's a methodology doomed to failure, and unless and until the antiracism movement figures that out, things will only go backwards and cause MLK to roll over in his grave.

Expand full comment
Jeff Dewey's avatar

Before the conversation can begin, we need to agree on a definition of "equal." MLK defined equal in terms of political rights and opportunity. The antiracists and even more moderate politicians define equality in terms of percentages and outcomes. Count me among those who favor the former term.

How do the proponents of structural racism theory account for President Obama's election? Or the great successes and accomplishments of many Americans who are black?

Expand full comment
7 more comments...

No posts