Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Frank Lee's avatar

The root cause of much of what is wrong in society today began with a giant mistake of adopting this opinion that we should criminalize an emotion and persecute people for using certain words that we would claim proved the emotion. What the hell was wrong with the people entrusted to protect our individual rights to allow this to happen.

The road to hell is paved with good intentions. The road back to system health will require we reverse course and ban hate criminalization as being unconstitutional.

Expand full comment
PSW's avatar

Wow, things have changed since the free-wheeling 70s when I was in college. My dorm mates would have probably been expelled or worse for hanging out a large banner saying "Nuke Iran" after the American hostages were taken in Tehran in 1979.

The problem with any kind of speech control is ultimately the interpretation of what constitutes hateful or threatening speech, or, as in the case of the proposed Board of Disinformation proposed by the Biden Administration, disinformation. Without distinct guidelines, you get cases where just the mention of the KKK warrants action, even when it's in the confines of literature or history.

When I was in college, Saturday Night Live was at its peak of enjoyment and entertainment, and nothing was sacred. I haven't watched in over 35 some years, but I suspect now it's a watered down version and apparently geared more toward mocking conservatives than anyone else. I also suspect George Carlin would likely be turned away for his brutal humor, not to mention Andrew Dice Clay or Lenny Bruce.

When even the ability to poke fun at ourselves is lost for fear of "offending" someone, we become no better than humor Nazis. I sincerely hope that never happens.

Expand full comment
8 more comments...

No posts