Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Mitch Barrie's avatar

This was a really very good 1,000 word elaboration of . . . common sense. It's a shame it even needs to be written (and 25 years ago I'm pretty sure it wouldn't have been necessary).

One point that stood out for me was your wonder whether any of the people behind these guidelines have ever met a five-year-old. Frankly, it has been apparent to me for a long time that most people high in the political realms of the education industry have not only never met any children, but don't even remember being children.

Expand full comment
Someone's avatar

There is absolutely no denying that racism exerts a profound and negative effect in public education. In Pittsburgh one need look no further than the radical disparities between Black and White standardized state scores in math, science and reading. It is absurd however to pretend more racism will fix this. And CRT is racism. Taken to its logical conclusion, CRT and its ilk will simply reduce the amount of math, science and reading that all children are taught, and worse these racist policies will mean funding dearly needed to improve teaching to help our underserved children succeed, will instead be wasted on a social experiment that has no evidence of helping our kids learn. Higher math and literary masterpieces will simply be eliminated from the public school curriculum, and wealthy children will hire private tutors to learn them just like the hire music teachers today. This is a coming catastrophe for Black and poor children. We need better teachers and better schools of education not reduced learning. The blame of this is clearly on American Schools of Education. My worst students for over 30 years as a college professor have generally been the elementary education students. The least well educated faculty I have met have been the professors of education. That is the problem. And that will be much harder to fix. CRT is a delusion.

Expand full comment
6 more comments...

No posts