Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Steve Stoft's avatar

Actually, as Mr. French points out, "the common view of the American right," which he summarizes at length, is "rooted in multiple events [on the left] that are real and, in fact, unjust." So he is listing evils of the left and of the right. I see this essay as quite balanced.

But if anyone thinks he has been too hard on the Right, remember that he is an Evangelical Christian and a conservative. So being hard on the Right is a sign of balance.

I think it's a wonderful essay and gets at the deepest cause of polarization -- each side sees the other as evil (when they are not) and seeing someone as evil is the main cause of hate.

I've thought a lot about why people make this mistake -- why they see evil when they shouldn't. What I think most people miss is captured in a famous proverb: "The road to hell is paved with good intentions." The common (and best) interpretation of this is that "good intentions" means only that the person on the road to hell truly believes his intentions are good (although they are not).

So the proverb tells us that when you see someone on the road to hell (doing terrible things) they are likely doing them out of a desire to do good. If you understand that, then it's hard to see them as evil. They are just mistaken. They have been misled. Everyone knows the proverb, but few are able to apply it.

I read the book. It's balanced and fascinating. See my (zFacts) review on Amazon.

Expand full comment
Adam O'Neil's avatar

this is really great, thank you

Expand full comment
31 more comments...

No posts