Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Unset's avatar

This essay is really not worth publishing. First of all, asserting that you opposed the Vietnam War when you were a teenager sixty years ago does not establish your credentials as a non-hawk. You can acknowledge the Iraq War was a catastrophe now. Did you oppose it then? Somehow I doubt it.

Life is complicated. It is possible to hold Putin primarily responsible and still acknowledge the US role in escalating the conflict the last twenty years.

"Others in the movement, such as Jeffrey Sachs, a former advisor to Sen. Bernie Sanders, argue that the war started with a U.S. coup in Ukraine in 2014 (the reality is that they were popular protests that led then-president Viktor Yanukovych to flee to Russia.)"

This is so dishonest that it shreds your credibility by itself. Yes, there were popular protests. There was also very prudent reasons to believe, with evidence, that the US intelligence community had a considerable role in what happened. To say nothing of the fact that even if there hadn't been, a mob rabble overthrowing the elected government because they didn't like a perfectly legal policy change is the very definition of a coup. ("The reality is that they were popular protests on January 6, 2021 that led then-president-elect Biden to flee to Canada.")

And as far as "the right of Ukrainians to determine their own strategy," when they don't need any help then they can do whatever they want. $100 billion in aid and counting buys a seat at the strategy table.

The reality of the situation is complicated and one can root for Ukraine while acknowledging that the war will end in a way that will likely make everyone unhappy, and not like a Disney movie were the heroes are victorious and the villian utterly vanquished.

Expand full comment
Frank Lee's avatar

A nicely woven tapestry supporting the American corporatist uniparty. Wars generate sales to the military industrial complex. They help the media generate cheap copy. They provide political wedge issues to campaign on. American liberals are now the warmongers because all of these things benefit their bank accounts. Russia is nothing. It is not a threat. But China is a massive threat. However, American liberals know where their bread is buttered.

Expand full comment
20 more comments...

No posts