Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Mark Kaplan's avatar

Dr. Persico I think you've articulated something that is very important. It is obvious to me that Jews have always been the object of projection from Western civilization, often the scapegoat. As we Jews stand as a symbol of difference, and at the core of Western thought and ideas about freedom and the value of individual life, we symbolize and receive the resentment of others. When you describe a "damning introspective critique", the logic follows that someone has to be blamed for that uncomfortable introspection - The Jews, as always. Dara Horn, in People Love Dead Jews, says it well: "Since ancient times, in every place they have lived, Jews have represented the frightening prospect of freedom.” Sartre articulates something similar in "Antisemite and Jew." All of this is remarkable for a country of 9 million, with only 16 million Jews globally. And we get 2/3 of all UN resolutions since 2015. We clearly represent something big, and your thesis is powerful. I have a perhaps naive hope that when the scapegoat (Israel/Jews) is able to stand in their full power, acting reasonably and in their interests, this would cause antisemitism to fade. After all, we haven't had the kind of visible power that Israel has for 2000 years prior to 1948. Your thesis is scary in that antisemitism just mutates as you say. The skeptical readers of your essay should remember that "what starts with the Jews, doesn't end with the Jews." Thank you for this, even though it depresses me.

Expand full comment
Michael Berkowitz's avatar

Very interesting, though the stuff about the "occupation" is balderdash. Israel is not "occupying" millions of Palestinians in any meaningful way; it's taking steps to keep those Palestinians from doing what we just saw Hamas do. And one can argue about what the ultimate disposition of Jews and Arabs should be in the land, but the '67 borders have nothing going for them except that they allow the Arabs to pretend that they didn't lose the war. If Dr. Persico wants to believe that we've stolen Arab lands and that "the settlers" -- as if the small rabble represents 500,000 people and as if their violence wouldn't be tame compared to a slow Monday night in Chicago -- are somehow the Jews' version of Hamas, he can flatter his conscience as he likes, but he's not describing reality.

Expand full comment
15 more comments...

No posts