Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Sally Satel's avatar

Thanks to all who wrote in. I just want to add yet another entry to the growing compendium of proof that scholarly standards are dropping precipitously.

For those with access, check out this two pager in jamapsychiatry_brown_2021_vp_210005_1628043316.03785 (2).

The paper's title" Cognitive Behavioral Therapy and the Implementation of Antiracism

Anyone who wants a pdf should email me at slsatel@gmail.com

This paper is yet another addition to what is becoming, to put it bluntly, a fraudulent literature on anti-racism in medicine. It is a jargon filled, echo chamber in which terms are rarely defined and it embodies the the well-known circular reasoning of the anti-racism movement: if you are not an anti-racist by our definition, then you are a racist. And every inequality is the result of implicit bias and structural racism - no questions allowed. Lastly, in the examples they give, they don't even control for race.

Expand full comment
TH Spring's avatar

Kudos to Ms. Satel and others for taking up the cause of the Individual in their field. The idea of personal agency and dignity lies at the heart of therapy, democracy and Western culture in general these past 300 years. Make no mistake, the neo-Marxists/neo-Racists are thrusting a dagger at that heart. So long as their philosophy of group identity, and more precisely their charge of systemic racism holds sway in elite circles, they will continue to bleed out the culture. Persuasion Community, take them on. Asking them to place nice achieves nothing. Counter their accusation directly and relentlessly. Fortunately, the case against them is easy to make. A handful of commentators are making it strongly. But a handful is not enough.

Expand full comment
14 more comments...

No posts