Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Wayne Karol's avatar

Good article. One thing I would add is that it's not just concept creep, but a combination of concept creep and concept contraction. The offense becomes more expansive when it's committed by Them and narrower when it's committed by Us. An obvious example is how the definition of racism has both expanded to where whites can't possibly be innocent and contracted to where Blacks can't possibly be guilty. And if we need a reminder that it's not just one side doing it, remember how during the Bush years the definition of terrorism both expanded for Muslims and contracted for everyone else, which is why some of the most enthusiastic supporters of the "War on Terror" were also defenders of the Irgun or the IRA.

And while maybe it's a bit of concept creep on my part to think that this is the place for it, I'd like to throw my name for the illiberal leftism that's gained so much power recently out there and see what people think. As Yascha points out in The Great Experiment, we could use a new one. Woke has become too cliche. Political correctness is too old-fashioned. Nobody can agree on how to define critical race theory. Successor ideology never caught on. And progressive is hardly the word for people who deny that we have made progress, who insist that America is just as racist as it was fifty or a hundred years ago.

So my term for it is "Costanza politics", from the Seinfeld where George decides to do everything by opposites. Because its premise seems to be that is traditional hierarchies of dominance are wrong, the opposite hierarchies would have to be right.

Expand full comment
Unset's avatar

Concept creep has also overtaken the word "literally" to muddy the waters even further. Metaphorically speaking, of course.

Expand full comment
18 more comments...

No posts