Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Peter Partee's avatar

Spot on. The sanctimonious presumption underlying the admonition to “just fucking educate yourself” is indeed that there is a some set of objective undeniable facts that we should be ashamed of not knowing and that we must learn and acknowledge and honor if racism is to be eradicated. The intellectual hubris of that presumption is tremendous and fundamentally illiberal as it allows for no possibility of differing interpretations (or to put it in post-mo sloppy speak: “no competing narratives.”). Foreclosing the possibility of a multiplicity of viewpoints preemptively triggers exactly the opposite of the intended reaction: in lieu of intellectual compliance and adoption of the mandated belief set, one resists. How about trying to persuade through dialectic? Racism‘ history, how to eradicate it, and what a post-racist world should look like—these are topics that deserve intellectual analysis and debate. Unless and until this lesson is learned, racial progress will stagnate, and gratuitous battle-grounds will be created.

Expand full comment
Doug's avatar

Nah. Not buying it. The assumption that "educate yourself" means you should come to a single objectively correct conclusion is a straw man. I'm a 62 year old white liberal and my daughter is a 22 year old socialist working full time as a prison abolitionist. She has encouraged me to learn about structural racism and the roots of law enforcement in the post-civil war South. I've been doing that so we can have a shared vocabulary and a common basis for discussion. We disagree about some things and she definitely has strong opinions, but the fact that I'm willing to consider her viewpoint and change some of my own thinking is what she means about educating myself. If you haven't put the effort into learning the basic history, then you can't have a meaningful conversation, including informed disagreements, about the state of race in America today.

Expand full comment
15 more comments...

No posts