Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Isabelle Williams's avatar

My daughter went to Dartmouth and I can confirm that her friends did not read much, they watch films and videos to relax. I remember reading one of her papers and chastising her for some poor writing and she told me, Mom, the other students write much worse. Then she shared with me a paper by another student and indeed it was not even worthy of a mediocre 10th grade student.

I think some of the blame needs to go to the absurd school system and its overstuffed but fatuous curriculum. Kids heads are stuffed with curriculum which they will need to pass AP tests. But engaging with reading actual books, and taking the time to think about an discuss ideas, is not done in any deep way.

The QUANTITY of what high schoolers on an elite track are expected to cover, destroys any QUALITY. Kids aiming for elite colleges will have 4 hours of homework a night, as well as extra curriculars and a full day of classes. This leaves no time to actually read for pleasure, whether assigned reading or not. It leads to a superficial type of intellect.

Expand full comment
Cranmer, Charles's avatar

I'm not sure where you get the idea that past generations did not actually read. Back in the early '70's we idolized authors like Vonnegut, Pynchon, Barth, Heller, Salinger, Bradbury, Rand, Robbins, Roth, and Asimov. And those were just the contemporary writers; no book was more widely read than Siddhartha. I'm not sure what generations since then have been up to, but if they haven't been reading they have a world of pleasure ahead of them if they make the effort. I'd give my right arm to encounter these folks again for the first time.

Expand full comment
35 more comments...

No posts