I think the very concept of “hate speech” is problematic. Who gets to define what is hateful? The concept that only certain groups can be victims seems to be enshrined in law. Or, offending a buffoonish politician (I am American) This was a sad story.
It's hard to imagine how any hate speech law could pass constitutional scrutiny here in the United States, barring some major divergence from caselaw in the Supreme Court. Even so, we shouldn't be complacent. Freedom of expression requires constant defense both legally and culturally.
I think the very concept of “hate speech” is problematic. Who gets to define what is hateful? The concept that only certain groups can be victims seems to be enshrined in law. Or, offending a buffoonish politician (I am American) This was a sad story.
It's hard to imagine how any hate speech law could pass constitutional scrutiny here in the United States, barring some major divergence from caselaw in the Supreme Court. Even so, we shouldn't be complacent. Freedom of expression requires constant defense both legally and culturally.
Well said, and a sorry state of affairs in Europe.