8 Comments
User's avatar
Isabelle Williams's avatar

The polarization in politics, at least among the educated upper middle class that I know best, has definitely increased. When I was growing up, my parents had friends who were democrats and friends who were republicans. And no one ever dreamed of accusing somone of a different party of being a morally inferior person.

The Obama period seemed to mark the beginning of more divisive politics. Democrats were accusing anyone who didnt support the Obama administration and their party, as being racist. Hilary Clinton used the sexist accusation. My experience is that democrats are very quick to call anyone who disagrees with them as racist and/or sexist. if you question open borders, you are racist. Democrat messaging actually said it was racist to question the covid vaccine, even though young black men were the demographic that was the most vaccine hesitant. ( and rightfully so!).

Expand full comment
Frank Lee's avatar

Correlation is not causation, but we should consider that the world has gone to shit as educated females have moved to dominate positions in society and the economy.

I have my own theory based on the science and observation that is rooted in evolutionary psychology... how females and males behave differently within group dynamics. Males are direct likely because they are stronger and more of a risk to each other, and thus they pound their chest and exhibit overt narcissism. There is a level of trust in that orientation. Females, probably because they are weaker and cannot directly challenge a male, have adopted covert narcissistic traits and strategies. The most difficult are those that bleed to vulnerable narcissism. It is common behavior that most husbands will identify... in a fit of rage she goes off on her husband and when he calls her on her bad behavior she cries and says "I am a terrible person" so that the husband hugs her and tells her she is a good person. This passive aggressive victim mindset approach is common in all female behavior. The problem is that there is no trust. Nobody knows exactly what the real agenda is. There is a two-faced presentation and hidden agendas. Politics is played in the backroom.

In my long corporate career managing workgroups dominated by both males and females, I have experienced this difference consistently. I am having to mediate conflict of feelings with the female workgroups. The males tend to work it out between themselves.

I believe the decline in our ability to talk to each other is because we have made the mistake to adopt a matriarchal house replacing the previous patriarchal house. We no longer trust each other. The agenda is hidden. Backroom politics has replaced honest and direct communication. Hypersensitive people have moved to the head of the class and replaced those with thick skin and high coping skills.

Hard times create strong men that create good times. Good times create weak men that create hard times. I believe we are living in a time of weak men and that is why things are not going well.

Expand full comment
Kenneth Crook's avatar

Why does a household have to be either matriarchal or patriarchal? Can't it be both?

Expand full comment
Bruce Brittain's avatar

As long as nearly half of voters within a society swim in a sea of disinformation, which they believe is true, talking to one another at a level that is productive it nearly impossible.

Expand full comment
Kenneth Crook's avatar

I think it's a lot more than half being exposed to disinformation - perhaps the vast majority, covering both sides of the "Right Opinion" fence mentioned.

Expand full comment
Alex's avatar

Amusingly, I think I could pair everyone who thinks this off with someone else who thinks this without ever having to pair two people who would admit to any agreement with the other

Expand full comment
Alex's avatar

> She felt the withering stare of the other mother: You live in one of the big houses. You are one of those.

I noticed that the entire scene of acrimony is theoretical. I wonder how much of the issue is formed by reasonable folks silently assuming everyone else is unreasonable, because the unreasonable people are too foolish to mind their own business. 70% of the world could be held hostage by the 15% and 15% who despise each other because we're too risk-intolerant to check!

Expand full comment
alexsyd's avatar

A Pepsi commercial from 1970? This is your answer to white supremacy – it being the greatest threat to the US, according to Joe Biden and his Secretary's of State and Justice?

Expand full comment